patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Local Voices

Middletown Library Board Confirms Branch Closings

At the December 19th meeting of the Library Board, it was announced that the Navesink, Bayshore, and Lincroft library branches would be closing as part of cuts to the library's 2013 budget.  The move is in response to declining revenues and saves approximately $200,000 annually. 

Residents who attended the meeting expressed concern that there had been insufficient coordination with schools, which develop curriculums with library resources in mind, and that little public input had been sought.   

Closures are not expected to occur until after the Board's re-organization meeting on January 16th. 

Maureen

10:54 am on Thursday, December 20, 2012

Why couldn't they leave the Lincroft branch open? It is far from the main branch and it is so convenient for residents. It is so sad to see such a busy branch be closed.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Karen Edmond

9:59 am on Monday, January 28, 2013

Your right. It's not a child friendly position at all.

Cat Lady

12:59 pm on Thursday, December 20, 2012

The closing of the three neighborhood library branches is very sad news to come out of last night's library board meeting. Yes, there will be financial savings, but the staff are on the higher level of clerical staff and will need to be relocated to the main branch. Many people who cannot get to the main branch will miss the convenience and personalized service that they receive at their local branch library. The Navesink branch has a rich history as the origins of the township library system and serves its community well. I suppose that the savings will be an asset, but it isn't always about money in the overall scheme of things. MTPL has loyal and dedicated patrons who have spent their entire lives using the library system and now are raising their children here to reap the benefits. What a shame that politics has to get in the way of a great library system with loyal employees and a great director.

Reply

Joe

2:41 pm on Thursday, December 20, 2012

@ Cat Lady. That "great director" as you put it is the one responsible for the closings. If it weren't for things like 6% raises, obscene travel expenses, unchecked hiring and hidden charges that the town has been picking up all these years, the branches would still be open. I take my hat off to the Library Board for doing the right thing for the taxpayers. I also always marvel at phrases thrown into financial discussions like "raising their children" meant to tug on the heartstrings - how very board of education of you.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jay Christopher

5:50 pm on Thursday, December 20, 2012

According to the union contract that expires this year, library employees received no increase in 2010, a 1% increase in 2011 and a 1% increase in 2012. So much for 6% raises.
As far as the town picking up hidden charges, the library is a TOWNSHIP library and tax money supports it.
Unchecked hiring? Obscene travel expenses? Would love to see some documentation rather than unsupported comments.

KS

5:06 pm on Thursday, December 20, 2012

What will happen to the buildings that housed these branches?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Linda Baum

2:52 am on Friday, December 21, 2012

There is a clause in the deed for the Lincroft branch, a former school house, that reverts ownership to the Board of Education if the Twp closes that library branch. The Bayshore branch is owned by the Twp and the property could potentially be sold. The Navesink branch is owned by the Duryea-Navesink Library Association, a non-profit, whose board decides how the building will be used. The Association provided the building for use as a library at no charge -- formal rent was $1.

Belford Bob

6:35 pm on Thursday, December 20, 2012

2007,2008, 2009. Six percent raises across the board. 18% over 3 years. no wonder why the bills are now coming due.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Linda Baum

3:29 am on Friday, December 21, 2012

As I mentioned in a prior post, the raises not only recognized the 2% health care contribution, but also sought to bring salaries to competitive levels to attract qualified staff. After three years, someone earning $25K would see a salary increase to only about $29K after the 2% contribution.

LJ

8:02 pm on Thursday, December 20, 2012

How convenient, after the township raided the Library's emergency fund
of coarse they have a shortage of funds. This paved the way for the closing of the branches.
It is indeed a sad day for the residents of Middletown

Reply

Gary Junstrom

8:54 pm on Thursday, December 20, 2012

Wow LJ you should probably stay away from the Democrat political mailers. If you were honestly looking into the facts you would know that aside from the massive amount of money the state forces the town to give to the library, the pension payments that were SUPPOSED to come from the library budget were made by the township. As I see it, that was a fraction of the money owed by the library back to the township. As the mayor pointed out, to make matters worse, the library director has been on a spending spree with a 6% raise for her employees, big time travel charges and overtime for Sunday hours. The taxpayers have had enough of this kind of spending and its time we put a stop to it.If the county wants it, the town should hand it over before they change their minds.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Naomi Carter

10:57 pm on Thursday, December 20, 2012

Well, Gary, first of all, the amount of money the library has to pay back top the township each year is determined by the CFO hired by the TC. If he makes an error, which he did this year, why is it that you are blaming the library? Also, if you would actually read any of the facts, the library staff HAS NOT RECEIVED 6% raises in many years, more like 1%. With regard to pensions and going to county system, why don't you check the N.J. public employee salaries/pensions (http://www.app.com/section/DATA/DataUniverse) so that you can see that Monmouth County Library staff do get pensions and many make more than the staff at the Middletown Public Library? Most libraries pay time and a half for Sundays if they are even open or hire outside staff to work just the weekends and they are paid a higher rate than the regular employees but without benefits. You might want to check your facts before making all these cost-saving assumptions. It seems YOU need to stay away from the Republican political mailers especially when the mayor knows full well that no library staff gets double time for Sundays yet states it on the patch. With that type of behavior, why should statements by the TC committee or the library board be believed?

Comment_arrow

Linda Baum

3:09 am on Friday, December 21, 2012

Travel costs were nominal and pertained to conference attendance for a few key staff who hold masters degrees in library science. The event allows staff to keep current with innovation in the field and thus was deemed a worthwhile expenditure.

Naomi Carter

11:03 pm on Thursday, December 20, 2012

oh yeah, BTW, township employees, like the police, township administration, parks and recreation, public works, all get pensions and most get larger raises than the library employees. Are you going to next attack these entities to make sure they don't get pensions or a decent wage?

Reply

07748

3:00 pm on Friday, December 21, 2012

Speaking of pensions, Rosemarie Peters spent 17 years on the township committee with a salary of just enough to be enrolled in the Public Employees Pension System. Now she makes $90K + a year. Her pension will be based on her 3 best years of earnings. Scharfenbagger is doing the same with the political plum job our "rock star Gov." gave him. Why does our Gov. let this grotesque abuse of a publicly funded pension system continue? Because he is nothing but a joke just like the rest of them, they are out for themselves, not us.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Joe

11:17 am on Saturday, December 22, 2012

07748 - you are obviously a Democrat and this state is run by your party. Rather than trash the greatest governor this state has ever had, you may want to call Democrat Steve Sweeney, the union guy, who is also a paid senator and a paid freeholder about the system that you are complaining about and that they created. Remember, it was the great Chris Christie who took on the unions and got them to pay more for their pensions and benefits. As for this library - it is about time someone pulled the plug on the jet set lifestyle of the director and her staff.

Comment_arrow

07748

8:25 am on Sunday, December 23, 2012

Joe- Where is the leadership from the Gov. on this pension issue? He claims to have garnered bi-partisan support for other pension reforms, why has he not taken on this one? And no, I am not a democrat, nor a republican. Proud to be one who can think for himself.

Comment_arrow

Joe

1:10 pm on Sunday, December 23, 2012

@07748 - the leadership is this: the governor managed to do the impossible which is to get the greedy unions to agree to pay more into their pensions and health benefits, something the Democrats fought tooth and nail. Christie is a minority in Trenton and as such, can't just wave a magic wand and do everything he would like. Just watch this year how the unions come out to try and knock Christie out as payback for his fighting for the taxpayers. As for the library, I understand that they are also union workers, which explains the obscene 6% pay raise and the overtime for working on Sundays. What they should do is stagger the work week, you know some people work Tues-Sun. so they will only be paid straight time. But then, the unions wouldn't be unions if they weren't squeezing every last dime out of the taxpayers. I hope the library board doesn't back down until they get to the bottom of all the spending at the library.

Comment_arrow

07748

9:15 pm on Sunday, December 23, 2012

Joe-What I find to be obscene is how politicians of both political parties work the pension system to their advantage and the taxpayers disadvantage. Someone who accumulates 17 years of time in a pension system while making a very, very small contribution to it, and then will cash out based on over a $90K salary is obscene. This abuse is wide spread throughout the state and no Gov., democrat or republican, has addressed it to any meaningful degree. How does one who earns such a nominal amount of money even qualify for a pension? In NJ they do because the politicians made it that way, politicians from both parties. We need a Gov. who has the guts to eliminate this abuse of taxpayers money.

John Pittner

6:51 pm on Friday, December 21, 2012

The Middletown Library System needs to be merged with the Monmouth County Library System. This will create a better system for the township and lower the cost to the tax payers. It’s only a matter of time when the elected officials, will see that the merger will benefit everyone in the township and the county.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Linda Baum

2:35 pm on Saturday, December 22, 2012

Advantages and disadvantages of moving to the county system need to be carefully weighed. There may be no cost savings. Details about the process and the numbers are being gathered. There are still many unanswered questions at this time. I will post about this when more is known.

Conservative Mom

7:38 pm on Friday, December 21, 2012

Joining the Monmouth County Library will not necessarily lower the cost to the Middletown tax payers. While right now the county library tax, (based on valuations), is around half the amount of the municipal appropriation (based on equalized valuations), the township of Middletown would still be responsible for the main branch building and grounds. Our municipal tax dollars would still pay for the library's utilities, snow plowing, landscaping, repairs, maintenance, improvements, communication lines, and anything else facility-related. That would come out of your township taxes in the township budget, so while it wouldn't be as obvious to you, the costs are still being paid by you. In the end, the cost will likely be the same. Go to the Monmouth County Library and ask them for a copy of their budget and you can see how they are spending the money. County Library Tax dollars won't necessarily be spent on the Middletown branch but right now our tax dollars stay in Middletown. The number of patrons who can utilize Middletown will increase when part of the county system, and unless the amount of materials is increased and the parking lot is expanded, you can't claim that the Middletown residents will be better off. Also worth mentioning is that in order to join the county library system, Middletown would be expected by the Freeholders to put the question up for public referrendum. Be careful what you wish for!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Linda Baum

3:41 pm on Saturday, December 22, 2012

Something that needs to be studied is whether there would be a significant shift in which branch Middletown residents use with a move to the county system. Most may continue to use the main branch on New Monmouth Road, which is going to see an increase in usage with the closure of the three smaller branches. Joining the county system would further increase the demand for resources there. We should measure these impacts before making any decision to ensure that residents' needs are being met.

Comment_arrow

Olivia Dunham

7:10 pm on Sunday, December 23, 2012

There is really no need to measure anything. We should just shut down the library. Get a kindle.

Parker Hilton

9:05 pm on Friday, December 21, 2012

Every library in the country needs to be shut down and the money saved used to lower taxes. Al gore invented the internet many years ago. The library has run its course and should be left to history.

Reply

Leave a comment